Sony has defeated a £2bn class action in the UK that accused the company of overcharging around 12.2 million PlayStation users for digital games and add-ons.
The Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) in London dismissed the case in its entirety on November 17th. "We have concluded that the Class Representative has failed to establish that Sony has infringed competition law," the panel of Ben Tidswell, Lord Richardson and Derek Ridyard said in its judgment.
The claim was brought by consumer campaigner Alex Neill, who argued that Sony used technical and contractual restrictions to stop rival stores from selling digital content to PlayStation users. According to Consumer Voice, the claim said players could have paid around 20% less if competing stores had been allowed.
Why the tribunal sided with Sony
The tribunal looked at competition across the wider gaming market rather than at the PlayStation Store alone. It found that physical games and rival platforms such as Xbox, Nintendo and PC gave consumers alternatives that limited Sony's pricing. It also said the market definitions used in the claim were an "unsafe" way to judge Sony's conduct, according to The Independent.
"Potential PlayStation console purchasers had both access to sufficient information and an incentive to consider that information in order to make informed purchasing decisions at the console level," the judgment read. The tribunal was not satisfied that Sony was dominant, and it found that the claim had not shown its typical 30% margin on digital sales to be excessive or unfair.
During the trial, Sony argued that allowing third-party stores would bring security and privacy risks. The company also said it sells consoles at a low margin to build its playerbase, and that its commission on digital sales helps cover those costs.
What happens next
No compensation has been awarded. Neill said she was "disappointed" by the ruling, adding: "This case has been five years in the making and raised important questions on behalf of 12 million UK consumers."
"We believe these were important issues to test on behalf of consumers and we are now carefully considering the judgment and our options, including whether to appeal this first-instance decision," Neill said. The tribunal has set a further hearing in the week beginning December 14th to deal with costs and any application for permission to appeal.