First Vote Deadlocked 3 to 3 Between Adults Only and Refusal... Passed 8-1 After Two Postponements

'GTA 6' Came Close to Rating Refusal in South Korea

Korean (한국어) Add us on

It has been confirmed that 'Grand Theft Auto VI' (hereinafter 'GTA 6') came close to receiving a rating refusal during its classification review in South Korea. In the first review held by the Game Content Rating Board (GCRB) on September 10, the vote was deadlocked at 3 votes for Adults Only (19+) and 3 votes for Rating Refusal. After two decision postponements, 'GTA 6' received an Adults Only rating by an 8-to-1 vote in its third review on October 16.

GTA6 Grand Theft Auto VI
©GCRB

According to the 'GTA 6' rating classification meeting minutes obtained by Inven on November 12, concerns among gamers prior to release about a rating refusal in South Korea were not groundless rumors. Throughout all three reviews, board members clashed over out-of-context genital exposure and the legal grounds for refusing classification.

Beyond simply determining the rating for a single major blockbuster, the proceedings exposed the lingering challenges facing private rating deliberation all at once.

Two Postponed Decisions: The Key Issue Was 'Out-of-Context Genital Exposure'

GTA6 Grand Theft Auto VI
©GTA6

The rating application for 'GTA 6' was submitted on September 1. When the first review on September 10 resulted in a 3-3 tie between Adults Only and Refusal, the board chose to postpone the decision following a recommendation for revision instead of reaching a conclusion. A playable build was delivered to the board only on September 28 due to security concerns. The second review on October 2 postponed the decision again, citing the need for "thorough playtesting". A meeting scheduled for October 8 did not take place due to a lack of quorum. In the third review on October 16, the rating was finalized with 8 votes for Adults Only and 1 vote for Refusal. The assigned content descriptors were Sexuality, Violence, Crime, Drugs, and Language.

The reason the game came close to refusal was not violence, but sexuality. What board members took issue with was the frequent appearance of male genital exposure in the background without sexual context. The consensus was that depictions of violence, crime, and drugs were not significantly different from 'GTA 5'. In 2013, 'GTA 5' received an Adults Only rating with content descriptors for Sexuality, Violence, Language, Drugs, Crime, and Gambling.

Behind the debate lies a regulation revision. Prior to the September 2025 revision, the rating classification regulations treated cases where "genitals are not completely exposed, but suggestive body exposure is excessively expressed" as Adults Only. After the revision, this wording was changed to "cases where suggestive body exposure is directly and specifically depicted." This relaxed the standard where genital exposure almost automatically led to rating refusal. 'GTA 6' served as a testing ground for applying the relaxed wording to a blockbuster title for the first time.

The issues extended beyond sexuality. Because rating refusal is an administrative disposition that effectively blocks domestic release altogether, board members repeatedly pointed out that clear legal grounds were necessary. It was also noted that the guidebook used to determine refusal based on sexuality lacks legal force, and that there are no refusal criteria at all for crime and drugs. The board's limitations in verifying content—such as whether members could fully check a game whose main story alone spans dozens of hours (n hours)—were also brought to light. The burden of South Korea being the sole country to refuse classification when 10 overseas rating bodies had already issued adult ratings was also mentioned.

The conclusion was Adults Only. However, the documents do not confirm how the revision recommendation issued in the first review was handled. Board members were mindful that this decision would set a precedent for future games. Suggestions followed to revise the regulations regarding out-of-context genital exposure and to establish internal rules.

1. September 10 First Review: Adults Only 3 Votes vs. Refusal 3 Votes

In the first review, board members discussed the level of sexual content for about 30 minutes. At that point, the board had not yet received a playable build. Below are key statements from board members presented in meeting minutes format. The statements have been polished based on the original document text without altering their original meaning.

Arguments for Refusal

Member A
: It is not that genital exposure is completely forbidden, but it has never appeared this frequently without context. We have allowed a certain degree of genital exposure when there is contextual justification. However, even outside of sexual act scenes, a rating has never been granted for genital exposure that appears out of context like this. Usually in such cases, we issued a recommendation for revision.

It is clear that the level of sexual content has become significantly higher than in the previous game. Under the old rating classification regulations, any genital exposure resulted in an unconditional refusal. We slightly softened the wording in the recent revision to allow some exposure that might be contextually necessary. I do not believe the current level of genital exposure is acceptable even under the revised standard.

Arguments for Adults Only (Approval)

Member B
: According to the rating classification guide, rating refusal requires that sexual acts as a whole—including depictions of body parts such as genitals, vulva, pubic hair, and anus—be depicted specifically and explicitly. In this game, scenes with heavy exposure are not particularly sexual. Conversely, exposure is restricted during sexual scenes. We must judge the content comprehensively.

This game's crime elements are stronger than its violence. However, since there are no refusal regulations for crime elements, I think it fits the Adults Only level. Drugs are also depicted specifically and explicitly, down to the player controlling the method of ingestion. I view this as quite problematic, but since there are no refusal criteria for it either, we have no choice but to pass it.

Member C: It is correct that crime elements cannot be used as grounds for refusal. Apart from that, even compared to 'GTA 5', which was rated by GRAC, it is hard to say that depictions of cruelty, crime, or drugs have worsened. If we respect the decision made for the predecessor, nothing major has changed other than sexuality.

Member A: Since the rating classification regulations are a higher-level norm than the guide, shouldn't we follow the regulations?

Member C: Even taking that into consideration, it is hard to say that elements other than sexuality have significantly intensified compared to the previous game.

Member D: While respecting the previous game, if ratings are being issued worldwide and news articles are published, there will also be a burden if South Korea alone holds back the rating.

Member C: Nevertheless, we should consider whether gamers actually feel sexual arousal from frequent male genital exposure. From the perspective of gamers playing this game, and considering that our society tends to be somewhat more tolerant of male exposure, we must carefully deliberate whether this truly reaches a level that stimulates sexual desires.

The vote resulted in a 3-3 tie. Member E summarized: "The vote came out 3-to-3 between Adults Only and Refusal. It is ambiguous whether the exposure is caused by game interaction or simply exposed in the background regardless." The board opted to postpone the decision following a recommendation for revision. The board communicated the reasons for the postponement to the publisher and asked if they intended to make revisions.

2. October 2 Second Review: Postponed Again for 'Sufficient Playtesting'

GTA6 Grand Theft Auto VI
©GTA6

According to the progress report document, the playable build was delivered only on September 28 due to security concerns. The reviewing researcher played the game focusing on the disputed issues from the Monday afternoon of the week of the second review until the morning of the meeting. The researcher explained that since the developer stated the main story alone takes over n hours, it was difficult to complete the story within the review period. The report added that because it is a game with high freedom, it is difficult to definitively find hidden elements unless disclosed by the company.

The researcher's playtest report served as the basis for judging sexuality. Most genital exposure scenes appeared as backgrounds in one-off missions or quests, and did not lead to sexual interactions. Because the map was vast, the locations containing exposure scenes were only found after repeatedly requesting maps from the publisher. Once there, players could do nothing except hit other characters without any sexual interaction, and the scene ended with the character being arrested by the police. The researcher also presented case studies of other games that received age ratings despite containing genital exposure.

Playtesting Verification Issues

Member E
: It is a sensitive game, so I wonder if it is okay for us not to examine content beyond what the publisher disclosed, and that is our biggest burden. Although 7 overseas agencies have issued ratings, don't we remain unaware of anything outside of what the publisher revealed?

Member C: I worry that if a rating is granted, unexamined parts we missed might become a societal issue. Conversely, if we do not grant a rating, criticism will arise that we refused it without thoroughly examining everything. We are in a situation where we must examine it as cautiously as possible.

Member F: Other games are not reviewed after playtesting every single situation either. If there are parts missed in 'GTA' this time, it is the fault of the publisher for failing to fulfill its reporting obligations. It is practically impossible for the board to review everything just to issue a rating.

Arguments for Refusal

Member D
: I don't think there is a big difference in gameplay compared to Grand Theft Auto V. The graphics have improved and content has expanded. What caught our attention is that there is far too much genital exposure. It feels like the company is constantly pushing the line. It comes down to whether we tolerate that line every time an entry in the series comes out.

Member A: There may be other games that received ratings despite containing nudity. But there will be quite a difference in detail and frequency. The guide states that even revealing a silhouette is grounds for refusal. Here, too, it is just static visuals without interaction. If it were only a nudist resort, one could say it is not obscene. But there are other explicit scenes. The explicit scenes of the protagonist couple themselves are not grounds for refusal. However, when viewing this kind of exposure alongside those scenes, it becomes difficult to claim the exposure is merely black humor.

Member H: The basic principle of rating refusal is when body exposure or sexual acts are depicted so explicitly or excessively that they disrupt social order. By that standard, the current bodily exposure is sufficiently explicit and excessive.

Member B: It is not exposed only during character creation or in special circumstances. It is an area visible throughout gameplay. Looking solely at the submitted content, I doubt we can pass it as Adults Only unless we change the criteria.

Arguments for Adults Only (Approval)

Member F
: The level of content is indeed intense. However, current standards are designed to target cases where sexual context or obscenity is prominent. When refusing a rating, while the guide is important, the legal aspects are far more crucial. Since the law contains provisions for refusal, we must examine whether the content fits what is explicitly specified in the law.

Member E: We must carefully look at how much these scenes account for in the overall volume. Because it is a game with high freedom, players can avoid those parts if they choose to.

Legal Grounds for Refusal

Member F
: Even if we set ratings up to Adults Only based on our guide, rating refusal is not a matter of classifying age ratings, but a major exercise of authority that blocks market release. We must look beyond our own standards and see whether we possess legal grounds sufficient to restrict that right. We must also evaluate whether we can claim we didn't restrict rights beyond the refusal criteria defined by statutes.

Member C: In lawsuits over rating refusal or revocation, the specific statutory provision relied upon had to be explicitly cited. If we issue a refusal, responding that it 'violates rating classification standards' will not suffice; we must conclude which specific article of the law it is based on.

Member E: If we issue a refusal rather than Adults Only, we need to secure that legal rationale to a certain degree.

Overseas Ratings and the Burden of 'Korea-Only Refusal'

Member E
: The reason we are implementing Stage 2 of the private transfer at the end of October is to align realistically with global standards rather than imposing excessive rating regulations. If overseas ratings are being issued and South Korea alone refuses it, that creates a significant burden.

Member D: If this game fails to receive a rating only in our country, it will become a massive issue. It effectively means we are the only ones globally not issuing a rating. If they had made it strictly based on GTA 5, we wouldn't be having this discussion. But they keep pushing the boundaries. Knowing that other regions, even Arab countries, have approved it makes it troublesome. Originally, violence was the main issue for this game, so in the past, we evaluated it based on violence.

Member C: Whether we refuse it or grant a rating, we must make a decision backed by the justification that we reviewed it as thoroughly as possible.

Member E: Refusing classification blocks the game's release. Articles will be published about this game whether a rating is issued or not, and whether we have playtested it sufficiently is what matters most. Once articles break out, defense falls on the board, so the researchers must thoroughly review it for us to defend our position. Refusal is the maximum authority we can exercise, and we must bear that responsibility. If simply feeling uncomfortable becomes the core of the judgment, we won't be able to defend it later.

Regulations and Precedents

Member B
: Further review is necessary, but if a rating is indeed granted, we should take this opportunity to consider revising regulations that classify mere genital exposure as grounds for refusal. If we refuse it, there is no need to change regulations. But if we release it as Adults Only, it is right to revise the sexuality regulations so that genital exposure without sexual context can be rated Adults Only. However, I am not sure if that aligns with our legal system.

Member C: I hope we proceed cautiously. This is not a matter that ends with rating this single game. If a rating is issued, it will also define our direction for future games that come after. If necessary, we should update the criteria.

Member E: We plan to hold an industry advisory meeting in Seoul in mid-October regarding the guidelines. Although we decided to make them public at the end of October, they were created internally without gathering external input. It is right to listen to industry feedback, make applicable revisions, and then disclose them.

The board postponed the decision once again, stating that further thorough playtesting review was required. The meeting scheduled for October 8 did not convene due to a lack of quorum.

3. October 16 Third Review: Adults Only by 8 to 1

GTA6 Grand Theft Auto VI
©GTA6

All nine board members attended the third review. The progress report summarized key considerations ahead of this session, placing at the top Article 3 of the Rating Classification Regulations—stating that "rating classification aims for international universal values"—along with status reports on overseas age ratings. As of October 16, 10 rating authorities—including North America's ESRB, Europe's PEGI, Australia, New Zealand, Taiwan, Germany, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, South Africa, and Brazil—had granted 'GTA 6' adult ratings. Saudi Arabia and the UAE assigned ratings for ages 21 and older. Japan's CERO had not yet reached a decision.

The legal basis was also organized. The progress report explicitly stated that the evaluation factors in the guidebook used to determine refusal based on sexuality were created internally by referencing educational materials from the Game Rating and Administration Committee (GRAC), and held no legal or regulatory force. As legal grounds for refusal, Article 22, Paragraph 2 and Article 32, Paragraph 2, Item 3 of the Game Industry Promotion Act, along with Article 44-7 of the Information and Communications Network Act, were examined. Beside the Information and Communications Network Act provision, a note was attached reading "Verification of applicability required."

The researcher reported the results of additional playtesting on the build. In scenes with genital exposure, sexual interactions were not possible, and no scenes showed higher severity than in previously received video footage. Problematic scenes from leaked overseas footage—specifically where character clothing was completely stripped or where players could manipulate the camera to view genitalia—were not confirmed in the current build.

The researcher categorized 'GTA 6' as an action-adventure game rather than a game intended for sexual acts. Scenes where male and female main characters build affection leading to sexual encounters could only be viewed passively like cutscenes, showing exposure up to the chest while genitals were not depicted. The reference game cited for comparison also featured genital exposure in the background, such as a nudist colony, and had been released domestically in South Korea. However, the researcher answered that the frequency of genital exposure was clearly higher in 'GTA 6'.

Arguments for Refusal

Member A
: Suppose we take genre characteristics into account and allow background genital exposure in adventures or RPGs while evaluating sexually suggestive games conservatively. I worry that genital exposure might frequently appear as background elements in RPGs going forward.

Arguments for Adults Only

Member B
: People may perceive it differently, but a game submitted earlier under a content modification report felt even more sexually suggestive because it actively pursued suggestive scenes, even though the exposure was covered up.

Member C: It appears they intentionally covered up genital exposure in sexually suggestive scenes while permitting exposure in background settings.

Member D: Games are created with a target audience in mind anyway. Games that lacked such elements won't all suddenly move in this direction. Rather than over-extrapolating, it is better to evaluate this game on its own.

Member E: Unlike setting an age rating, refusal is an administrative disposition that requires clear legal backing, and I understand there are relevant court precedents. If we refuse based solely on rating classification regulations, those are merely internal operational guidelines of an administrative body and cannot serve as legal grounds. We must find statutory backing, and that aspect concerns me.

Member F: Taking this case as an opportunity, how about establishing internal rules—similar to film ratings—that treat simple genital exposure without sexual expression as Adults Only?

Member G: Subjectivity is bound to enter into whether something is obscene or not. I think each member can judge for themselves.

The voting outcome was 8 votes for Adults Only and 1 vote for Refusal. Even in the final review, a vote for refusal remained to the end. The content descriptors were set as Sexuality, Violence, Crime, Drugs, and Language. Fear and Gambling, which had been flagged as harmful items in the preliminary review report, were excluded during the board's review.

The game publisher had requested that the classification result remain non-disclosed until the release date on November 19. The earlier news was essentially a leak.

4. What Changed After the Revision Recommendation?

GTA6 Grand Theft Auto VI
©GTA6

'GTA 6' will be released on November 19. However, it remains unconfirmed how the revision recommendation issued by the board during the first review was handled. According to the progress report, following the 3-3 vote on September 10, the board communicated the reason for the decision's postponement to the company and asked if they intended to make revisions. What response the company provided, or which scenes were actually modified, does not appear in subsequent meeting minutes or progress reports.

The records from the third review also fail to clarify whether modifications took place. The researcher reported that problematic scenes from leaked overseas videos were not confirmed in the current build. It remains unknown whether the developer removed those scenes in response to the revision recommendation or if they were never present in the release build to begin with.

On the other hand, the out-of-context male genital exposure that was the central issue in the first review remained a topic of discussion in the third review. The researcher answered that the frequency of genital exposure in 'GTA 6' was clearly higher than in the reference game. It is highly likely that the final judgment was made without major changes to the scenes that prompted the revision recommendation in the first place.

If so, the reason the vote shifted from 3-3 to 8-1 appears to lie not in changes to the game itself, but in the board's judgment. The board directly playtested the build and confirmed that there were no sexual interactions in the exposure scenes. They also repeatedly emphasized that since a rating refusal is an administrative disposition, its legal grounds must be clear. The fact that 10 overseas rating authorities had issued adult ratings also influenced the judgment. That this conclusion was reached after careful deliberation deserves positive recognition.

The vacuum regarding legal grounds remains as well. Article 32, Paragraph 2, Item 3 of the Game Industry Promotion Act—which was examined as grounds for refusal—prohibits the production and import of games that "excessively depict crime, violence, obscenity, etc.," and "are feared to disrupt social order". This is the exact provision against which gamers filed a constitutional complaint in October 2024, arguing it violates the principle of clarity. The rating members themselves essentially questioned whether a single vague provision could block the release of a major blockbuster.

Another lingering question is what the revision recommendation procedure actually changed. If the board demanded revisions and the developer did not make them, then the revision recommendation served merely as a tool to delay a decision. If the developer modified parts of the game, then understanding which modifications changed the board's decision would serve as the most useful standard for future games. Either way, it is information that the industry needs to know.

Ultimately, there is still no clear wording to signal in advance whether the next game presenting similar scenes will pass or be refused. How far out-of-context exposure will be allowed, and which statutory article will form the basis if refused, are questions raised by the board members themselves. To this, the question of what changed after the revision recommendation must be added. Presenting those answers as public standards is the next task facing private rating review.

Originally written in Korean, this article was translated with AI assistance and edited by a native English-speaking editor. Every translation is reviewed by our editorial team before publication. [Read Original]